In blast times, eunuch goes to donate blood, is turned away

Stories of callousness of hospitals is not new. Refusing beds to the terminally ill, denying care to the sick, making them wait for hours for an appointment…the list is endless.
And now, in blast times, if a recent incident at Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital is to be considered a case in point, there is discrimination against those who want to help, also. 
After the blasts, many people came forward to help and donate blood. Among them was Sita—a eunuch. After hearing of the plight of the victims of Saturday’s blasts, Sita wanted to help and went to RML Hospital where the doctors refused to accept her blood and turned her away. 
This, apparently, at a time when the hospital would have needed as much blood as possible!
For the doctor at the blood bank, the fact that Sita was a eunuch was enough to send her on her way. “When I went to donate blood on Saturday around 10 pm, Dr Veena Doda, the blood bank incharge, said they did not need a eunuch’s blood and turned me away,” Sita said. Shockingly, this happened at a time when dozens of injured people had been brought to the hospital for treatment.
Harsh Malhotra, secretary general, Delhi Pradesh National Panthers Party, who witnessed the incident on Saturday night, said, “It is human blood after all and in times of crisis such attitude is not acceptable. The doctor misbehaved with Sita just because she is a eunuch.”
While confirming that there was a shortage of blood at the hospital, Rahul Verma of Uday Foundation—a non-profit organisation for congenital defects and rare blood groups—said, “I got phone calls from anxious relatives of victims telling me that the hospital was short of blood that evening,” he said.
A NACO survey shows that, voluntary donation in Delhi is only 24 per cent. “Blood shortages are a regular feature and if hospitals are turning away donors then obviously there are no plans to increase blood donation.”
Denying any knowledge of the incident, Medical Superintendent, Dr N.K. Chaturvedi, said, “At the time of the blast we had 250 units of blood of all blood groups. Many voluntary organisations came and donated blood but then we redirected the donors to Red Cross as it is centralised and all hospitals could get blood from there.” He, however, added that there was a blood donation camp at the hospital on Sunday and Monday.
But why was Sita refused? Was it because she is a eunuch? “That you have to ask Dr Doda as she is the incharge of the blood bank,” said Dr Chaturvedi. Efforts to contact Dr Doda, however, failed.
What’s more, even the law has provisions that prevent people like Sita from exercising their duty as a citizen.
When asked, Aditya Bandyopadhyay, a gay lawyer, says, “According to the Blood Safety Regulation, there is a clause in the form (which the donor has to fill) that asks if the donor is male or female. If the answer is none, then the doctors can refuse to take blood from such a donor.” He adds that so long as Article 377 is alive, such discriminatory clauses would remain.

Would you rate this as discrimination? Should eunuchs be given equal rights?

8 Comments

Filed under Delhi, Nation

8 Responses to In blast times, eunuch goes to donate blood, is turned away

  1. Chaynika Thareja

    Eunuchs must be given equal rights.Afte all they are also human beings and if God made them special and different then that is not their fault.In consult with the article Sita who was refused to donate her blood atleast had the heart to go and make an effort in the deed of helping the people.And the funniest part is that the doctors who are placed as God in india are losing their humanity with every blast occuring.
    Everybody is aware of the fact that hospitals face a lot of blood crises still doing discrimination is something very inhuman.At the end of it the doctors should understand that scientificaly the blood doesnot changes and nobody will put a tag on the blood sample whether it is a eunuchs blood or not.
    Chaynika Thareja
    Delhi

  2. Rahul Sharma

    Well, according to me this is nothing but discrimination only. Eununchs no doubt deserve equal rights. I mean we are living in the 21st century but its really sad to see that the most educated & respected people of all i.e. the doctors have done this.
    This shows that even if a patient is dying & needs blood, the “bhagwans” of our country still would prefer them to die instead of taking blood from eununchs.
    This is something which should be aken tseriously and the concerned doctor must be punished for the same.

  3. Its sad to see such discrimination in a metropolitan city such as Delhi. I thought that at least in times of crisis and need, people come together, forget all differences and help each other out. But I can clearly see that discrimination is only increasing, and is nowhere near to getting over. What is even more amazing is that this kind of attitude comes from a doctor, who I assume knows pretty well that medically, there is no difference in the blood of a eunuch.

  4. Tarun Chandran

    The laws should be changed. India’s pseudo democracy is discriminating Dalits, sexual minorities and religious minorities. In the past few days we have seen Muslim youth getting killed in Delhi in the name of terrorism. We have seen Dalits and adivasis getting tortured through out the country on every day basis, with recent examples from Chengara in Kerala. We have seen Christian nuns burnt alive in Orissa.

    Among these multiple marginalisations and discrimination hijras and other sexual minorities are not even considered humans. We donot even have a coulmn to fill in except male or female. We are not citicens yet to even consider the violence on us as human rights violations.

    The law should change, we have equal rights. It is the same blood, which run on our bodies, on homosexuals and transsexuals…

  5. It refers to welcome new role for eunuchs in Bihar to be posted as safety-guards at girls’ hostels, colleges and hospitals for best utilizing third-gender’s abnormal physique for public-good. Otherwise also, Union government should announce unrestricted admission to any educational institution for free education to eunuchs without needing any reserved quota. Government should be duty-bound to make eunuchs join mainstream with parents of new-born eunuch child neither allowed nor necessitated to deject their eunuch-child to be handed over to isolated society of old eunuchs for begging, dancing or resorting to some anti-social activities. Rather there should be special job-reservation for nature’s abnormal creation of third-gender citizens.

    MADHU AGRAWAL
    (Guinness Record Holder for letters in Newspapers)
    1775 Kucha Lattushah
    Dariba DELHI 110006 (India)
    Tel 23253636
    Mobile 9810080011
    Fax 23254036
    E-mail subhashmadhu@sify.com
    Web http://www.subhashmadhu.com

  6. Alexwebmaster

    Hello webmaster
    I would like to share with you a link to your site
    write me here preonrelt@mail.ru

  7. jagadish

    Hey my name is Jagadish. from Bangalore..
    yes it is a pathetic condition in India for the eunuchs.
    people should concedier them also as living human beings…
    they have only mental issues not anything else.. people should understand what they are doing?

    I started a Technical course center in Bangalore for them to live in dignified life in this society.. if any one need any help please contact me
    my email id is mjagadish.97@gmail.com
    cell. 9036391205

  8. Pingback: India Non Profit News – Uday NGO India News | Uday Foundation - NGO in Delhi, children health ngo india

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s